The Importance of Legal Defense in Personal Injury Lawsuits
Personal injury lawsuits can be challenging to defend, especially when the plaintiff’s legal counsel presents compelling supporting documentation and identifies the parties who may have been negligent in their duty of care towards the injured individual. Automobile accidents, for example, often involve a thorough police investigation that lists all the parties involved, making it relatively easy to establish the basis of a personal injury case. These cases usually arise after extensive negotiations regarding the specific injuries and the resulting damages. In slip and fall personal injury cases, however, the dynamics are slightly different. Nonetheless, automobile accidents regularly involve multiple parties seeking to recover damages, which can lead to complex cases where defendants and their insurance companies attempt to minimize their fault and shift responsibility to others involved. It is crucial to have an experienced personal injury lawyer to defend your case effectively.
Challenging the Plaintiff’s Assertions
In some instances, invalid or overstated assertions made by the plaintiff can be stricken from the record if their legal counsel fails to provide sufficient evidence. This includes claims of exaggerated pain and suffering as well as calculated loss of future wages. Medical professionals’ diagnoses and prognoses can also be evaluated and defended, often with the help of an impartial medical expert who can provide an alternative analysis. While these challenges may not result in a case dismissal, they can lead to the elimination of certain items and a closer examination of the degree of injury, ultimately reducing the available financial damages.
Examining the Duty of Care
In any lawsuit, the plaintiff must establish that the respondent owed them a duty of care. However, in some cases, the initial filing fails to meet this standard by failing to establish a reasonable connection between the respondent and the accident that caused the injury. This defense is more commonly used in premise liability personal injury claims, as automobile accidents often have better documentation such as police reports and ambulance records. In cases filed against a business operator, claims may be misdirected if the actual property owner is the one who should be held liable. The viability of this defense will depend on the specific details of the lawsuit.
Comparative Negligence: Holding the Plaintiff Responsible
The defense of comparative negligence comes into play when the plaintiff bears some responsibility for their own injuries. Various states employ different variations of comparative negligence laws. Pure comparative negligence allows injured parties to receive financial compensation unless they are completely at fault for their injuries, such as in cases of intentional acts or when convicted of drunk driving. Modified comparative negligence laws, on the other hand, bar plaintiffs from any financial recovery if their negligence percentage is higher than that of the respondent. This bar level is typically set at either 50% or 51%. In pure contributory negligence states, any contribution to the cause of the injury can be an effective defense strategy. In premises liability cases, the focus is on the individual’s reasonable assumption of risk based on their actions. For example, trespassers who are injured often lose their claims because they have no authority to occupy the property. The specifics of the claim and the laws of the state can significantly impact the outcome, potentially leading to a case dismissal or reduced financial liability.
The Impact of Timely Filings
Many personal injury claims stem from injuries that initially seem less severe but later develop into serious conditions requiring ongoing medical treatment. All states have statute of limitations laws that determine the timeframe within which a personal injury lawsuit must be filed. Defense attorneys can effectively use this defense if a case is filed at the end of the limitations period, especially if the injury was recognized much earlier. Late filing may raise questions about the seriousness of the injury and could result in a dismissal due to the claim being considered frivolous.
Insurance Companies as Allies
It’s essential to recognize that your insurance company can be your strongest ally when defending against a personal injury lawsuit. Insurance companies have a vested interest in thoroughly investigating claims. In fact, they often provide legal counsel to their clients because it benefits both parties to explore every possible avenue of defense. Insurance claims adjusters and defense attorneys are experienced in handling personal injury claims and understand the intricacies of negotiations, including the possibility of taking a case to trial in hopes of a favorable jury verdict. Even valid personal injury claims are more likely to yield a favorable outcome when every detail surrounding the case can be effectively presented in court. Hiring a qualified personal injury lawyer in Las Vegas or Summerlin ensures the best possible result when defending against a personal injury case.
Image source: Garrity Traina
